If It Was Still Around Today, This Mt. Pleasant Eatery Would Probably Be Killing It

The ever-evolving Restaurant Graveyard series looks back at the countless, long-shuttered establishments that helped to propel Vancouver’s food and drink forward. Full A-Z with maps and photos here. May they never be forgotten!

Cafeteria was a short-lived, 30 seat restaurant from serial restaurateurs Chris Stewart and Andrey Durbach (see also “Parkside” and “Etoile” in the Restaurant Graveyard). It lasted two years in the heart of Mt. Pleasant at 2702 Main Street, opening in the summer of 2010 and closing in 2012. Previously, the address was home to a cult-hit looker called Ping’s Cafe.

Though definitely expressed with a European accent, Cafeteria’s concept cleaved close to no particular cuisine style. Stewart and Durbach wanted a no-frills, “super casual” eatery with a short and sweet wine list to compliment an ever-changing menu featuring dishes that never exceeded $20. The design, simple but slick, kept customer focus on what was on the plate and in the glass.

The opening day menu included the delicious likes of “Nobu-style” tuna and prawn sashimi, chicken schnitzel with spaetzle, Dungeness crab tortelloni, and butterscotch pudding. (I still vividly remember the schnitzel, which was superb.)

Stewart and Durbach sold the space to chef Andrea Carlson and her partner, Kevin Bismanis, who would soon thereafter open the award-winning and critically acclaimed Burdock & Co. in its place.

From my notes at the time, dated October 25, 2012:

Cafeteria owners Andrey Durbach and Chris Stewart knew that Carlson was looking for a spot in the area, and they were looking to down-size their far-flung operation without taking a loss (they also own Pied-a-Terre, La Buca, and The Sardine Can). A chat here, an email there, and the deal was done. All was set and signed back in September, but it wasn’t until last week that Carlson got the keys. She and Bismanis are hoping to turn it into a 30 seater – called Burdock & Co. – before the end of November.

Though I wouldn’t want to trade Burdock & Co. for Cafeteria, I can’t help but pine for the latter a little, and not just because the schnitzel was so good. The place was simple, focused and capable, and there was always something magic and interesting to be had.

The following images were taken just hours before Cafeteria’s very first guests were served. Take a good, close look at the menu shots. Don’t you think Cafeteria would be killing it if it was still around today?

  • Cafeteria
  • Cafeteria
  • Cafeteria
  • Cafeteria
  • Andrey & Chris | Cafeteria
  • Cafeteria
  • The first menu | Cafeteria
  • Cafeteria
  • Cafeteria
  • Cafeteria
  • Cafeteria
  • Cafeteria
  • Branding | Cafeteria
  • Cafeteria

There are 3 comments

  1. I loved the place and the name Cafeteria is still on the glass so likely will never go away!

  2. On Davie circa 99ish there was a little place called Random. Was high end food and super affordable…lots of wine and classic preparation..did pretty good for a few years then the soace because Lolita’s. They had amazing food! Was owner operated by 2 young chefs.

Restaurant Graveyard

Award-Winning Italian Restaurant Permanently Closes After 12 Years on Main Street

We can't blame greedy landlords or property developers for this one. Campagnolo was closed by Covid-19, plain and simple.

Five Years Ago Today, This Recently Shuttered Restaurant Got Off to an Excellent Start

Royal Dinette, launched in the Financial District in the summer of 2015, was the first local restaurant to fall during the pandemic.

Remembering the Promising Chinatown Restaurant and Bar That Never Really Caught On

The 80-seat Juniper lasted five years at 185 Keefer Street having never fulfilled its pre-opening promise.

Remembering the Hotel Restaurant and Bar That Championed Local Seafood

Yew in the Four Seasons (2007-2020) set an example of what a hotel restaurant could be in city in search of its culinary identity.