YOU SHOULD KNOW | About The Many Weird Visions Of Vancouver That Never Came To Be

May 25, 2017.

Civic-Centre-proposed-79-10

by Christine Hagemoen | Vancouver, like all cities, is constantly evolving. Buildings come down, buildings go up. Neighbourhoods change. Over the years architects, planners and developers have yearned to leave a lasting mark on our city. Some were able to realize their dreams, many were not. Take a look at several city-altering designs from decades past that never quite made it — I like to refer to them as the good, the bad and the beguiling.

In 1926, the consulting firm of Harland Bartholomew & Associates was hired by the Vancouver Town Planning Commission to prepare a comprehensive town plan – Vancouver’s first. Bartholomew presented the first plan in 1928, later revised in 1929 after amalgamation. He also prepared further town planning reports in 1944 and 1948. While not all of his plans and concepts were realized, Bartholomew’s ideas highly influenced the overall plan of Vancouver. Much of what we see today has a basis in his plans.*

One of Bartholomew’s more fanciful proposals was for this Civic Centre (see photo at top). The desire for a new civic centre and city hall was already in place when this drawing was commissioned in 1928. John F.D. Tanqueray’s drawing (for Harland Bartholomew & Associates) shows Vancouver City Hall located in the West End beside the yet-to-be-built Burrard Bridge. It’s likely that this plan could have been realised if Vancouver didn’t amalgamate with South Vancouver and Point Grey in 1929. After amalgamation, a more “centralised” location for the new City Hall was sought, resulting in the current location of City Hall today. The only part of this plan that was actually built was the Burrard Bridge (1932). Imagine if City Hall was located above Sunset Beach. Now imagine City Hall above Sunset Beach on 4/20!

IMG_5725

Another plan for a civic centre (sans City Hall) was suggested in 1945 by Park Commissioner, George Thompson. This scheme along Georgia Street from Howe to Stanley Park is the more ambitious of the two civic centre proposals illustrated here. With its centre boulevard (of what appear to be blossoming cherry trees) and its Dr. Seuss-like curvilinear streets and overpasses, the plan also includes a variety of civic buildings: Administration, Library, Polytechnic School, Theatre, Auditorium, Museum, Art Gallery, Art School, and Nursery & Day School. Though it certainly looks compelling on paper, it’s hard to say how this would have worked in reality. Personally, I don’t think it would have aged very well. This plan also required the city to purchase a large portion of downtown — I’m sure that would have been a hard sell to taxpayers…
LEG26

Many of you will know about the various schemes in the middle of the last century to “clean up” the so-called “blight” of the East End of Vancouver (now known as Strathcona) with the elimination of Hogan’s Alley being the most infamous. The drawing above, part of the 1957 Vancouver Redevelopment Study, shows a complete overhaul of Strathcona. Tearing down the majority of existing buildings and dwellings of the neighbourhood in favour of high-rises, row houses and walk up apartment buildings, creating what planners hoped to be a utopian social housing community. In reality, it would have most likely turned into a ghetto. This kind of “scorched earth” approach to urban development and public housing projects was popular all over North America during this time. This was beautifully illustrated in the 2016 documentary, “Citizen Jane: Battle for the City” (The film tells the story of journalist, author and activist Jane Jacobs’s struggle to save New York City from urban developers.)

On the other side of the city there were two proposed schemes for the “improvement” (development) of Spanish Banks in the 1920’s: a harbour port and an airport.

LEG1362

This plan for Spanish Banks port terminals along the foreshore of Point Grey was proposed by the Vancouver Terminals Co. in 1923. The drawing shows terminal plans and amplification of harbour facilities superimposed on the original layout of Spanish Banks improvements proposed in 1910 by A.K.H. MacFarlane, a clerk with the Harry A. Johnston Real Estate Company. Knowing how far out the low tide mark is at Spanish Banks, I can’t even fathom how anchorage this would even be possible, notwithstanding the fact that a port terminal at Spanish Banks would have been a crime against nature.

MAP-377

Saved from the Vancouver Terminals Co.’s proposed port facility monstrosity, Spanish Banks was once again under the developer’s eye when this plan for the design of Vancouver Airport at Spanish Banks came to light in 1928. Accommodating both land and seaplanes along with surrounding gardens, a stadium, parks and beaches, this plan was overzealous in the variety of services on offer. Do we really want children floating in a 4-foot-deep wading channel right next to an airport runway? Fortunately, saner heads prevailed and in 1930 land on Sea Island was obtained for YVR.

LEG1709

It’s hard to imagine the following proposal ever going ahead today, that is unless, of course, it included a bike lane. But imagine a pedestrian-only suspension bridge across the First Narrows. It’s believed this architectural drawing for a proposed footbridge is dated May, 1909. The drawing consists of a plan and elevation of the structure. It also includes a location map showing the span of the bridge in the context of Stanley Park and the North Vancouver shoreline. Though it is hard to tell from the drawing, it appears one would have to climb and descend staircases within the towers to access the bridge span, making this a test of acrophobia as well as endurance.

Finally, wouldn’t Vancouver be better with more public washrooms? Especially if they looked like these:

LEG288

I know many a desperate trip walking home across the Granville Bridge after a night out would have been easier if this “public convenience” was greeting me at the other end (below). There is always a point mid-span when the urge hits you, and you curse yourself for not hitting the “can” before you left the pub.

LEG288

Curiously, there are numerous historical plans for “public conveniences” (washrooms) found in the City of Vancouver archives holdings that, to my knowledge, were never built. I suppose when budgets are tightened, so go the plans for public conveniences. Besides, there are always the alleys.

——————————————————-

*If you want to read more about Bartholomew’s plans check out A Plan for the City of Vancouver, Harland Bartholomew & Associates, 1928; Transit Planning , 1946; and The Appearance of the City , 1947 available on the Internet Archive. To learn more about Harland Bartholomew and the City of Vancouver click here.

#ScoutThis

There are no comments

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You Should Know Local histories and mysteries...

YOU SHOULD KNOW | About The Old Building That’s Now Home To Andina Brewing Company

YOU SHOULD KNOW | About The Old Building That’s Now Home To Andina Brewing Company

by Christine Hagemoen | One of my favourite things to do on a weekend afternoon combines my love of craft beer with my love of local history. This often takes… more 

YOU SHOULD KNOW | All About The Sidewalk Stamps Still Spelling Out Vancouver’s History

YOU SHOULD KNOW | All About The Sidewalk Stamps Still Spelling Out Vancouver’s History

1906 date stamp on an early sidewalk at Hastings & Richards (City of Vancouver Archives - CVA 677-584) by Christine Hagemoen | As someone who commutes… more 

YOU SHOULD KNOW | About The ‘Easter Be-In’ That Occurred In Vancouver 50 Years Ago

YOU SHOULD KNOW | About The ‘Easter Be-In’ That Occurred In Vancouver 50 Years Ago

by Christine Hagemoen | Yesterday - Sunday, March 26th, 2017 - marked the 50th anniversary of the first “Be-In” held in Vancouver. The event marked a huge… more 

YOU SHOULD KNOW | About The Piece Of Vancouver History That Just Sold For A Song

YOU SHOULD KNOW | About The Piece Of Vancouver History That Just Sold For A Song

by Christine Hagemoen | Vancouver’s oldest wood-frame commercial structure - the subject of a famous Fred Herzog photograph (below, then and now) - is… more 

YOU SHOULD KNOW | About Groundbreaking Eleanor Collins, The City’s ‘First Lady Of Jazz’

YOU SHOULD KNOW | About Groundbreaking Eleanor Collins, The City’s ‘First Lady Of Jazz’

by Christine Hagemoen | I think everyone in Vancouver should know about Eleanor Collins. Some of you may already know and admire the glorious singer, but I… more 

YOU SHOULD KNOW | About The ‘Bottle Dash’ Houses That Still Glitter In The Vancouver Sun

YOU SHOULD KNOW | About The ‘Bottle Dash’ Houses That Still Glitter In The Vancouver Sun

by Christine Hagemoen | You have passed them a thousand times and not even noticed. Then one sunny winter day a glint of light catches your eye. Why is that… more 

YOU SHOULD KNOW | Our City Streets Were Once Paved With These Little Wooden Blocks

YOU SHOULD KNOW | Our City Streets Were Once Paved With These Little Wooden Blocks

by Christine Hagemoen | Right beside the historic 106-year-old Patricia Hotel on the Downtown Eastside lies a remnant of Vancouver’s “lumber town” past… more 

YOU SHOULD KNOW | The Explanation Behind The Odd Granite Obelisks Of Mount Pleasant

YOU SHOULD KNOW | The Explanation Behind The Odd Granite Obelisks Of Mount Pleasant

by Christine Hagemoen | The first time I noticed the odd little granite obelisk pictured above on the corner of E 11th and Ontario was just over a year ago… more 

The scout Community

49th Parallel Coffee Roasters & Lucky’s Doughnuts Acorn Agrius Ai & Om Alibi Room Ancora Waterfront Dining & Patio Anh and Chi AnnaLena Araxi Arbor Ask For Luigi Au Comptoir Bao Bei Chinese Brasserie Bar Oso Bauhaus Beach Bay Café & Patio Beaucoup Bakery & Cafe Bel Café Bestie Bishop’s Bistro Wagon Rouge Bittered Sling Blue Water Cafe + Raw Bar Botanist Bottleneck Boulevard Kitchen & Oyster Bar Bufala Burdock & Co. Cabrito Cacao Cadeaux Bakery Café Medina Caffè Artigiano Camp Lifestyle + Coffee Co. Campagnolo Campagnolo ROMA Cartems Donuterie Chambar Chefs’ Table Society of BC Chez Christophe Chocolaterie Patisserie  Chicha Chill Winston ChocolaTas Chocolate Arts Cibo Trattoria Cinara CinCin Ristorante + Bar Cioffi’s Cioppino’s Mediterranean Grill Cocktails & Canapes Catering + Events Cook Culture Culinary Capers Catering & Special Events Dirty Apron Cooking School & Delicatessen District Brasserie Dixie’s Authentic Texas BBQ Earnest Ice Cream East Van Roasters Cafe Edible Canada El Santo Elementa Espana Fable Fanny Bay Farmer’s Apprentice Fat Mao Fayuca Fernwood Coffee Company Field & Social Forage Giovane Cafe + Eatery Gotham Steakhouse & Bar Grain Granville Island Grapes & Soda Greenhorn Espresso Bar Gyoza Bar Hart House Restaurant Harvest Community Foods Hawksworth Restaurant Heirloom Heritage Asian Eatery Homer Street Cafe & Bar Hy’s Steakhouse Irish Heather Jamjar JJ Bean Joe Pizza Joy Road Catering Juice Truck Juke Fried Chicken Juniper Kafka’s Coffee & Tea Keefer Bar Kin Kao Kissa Tanto Knifewear Kozakura Kuma Tofino L’Abattoir La Buca La Mezcaleria La Pentola La Quercia La Taqueria Pinche Taco Shop Les Amis du Fromage Lions Pub, The Liquidity Bistro Lobby Lounge + RawBar Longtail Kitchen Lucha Verde Made By Pacific Maenam Mak N Ming Mamie Taylor’s MARKET by Jean-Georges Matchstick Coffee Roasters Meinhardt Fine Foods Miku Restaurant Milano Coffee Minami Miradoro Mission Mister Mogiana Coffee Mosquito Nero Belgian Waffle Bar Nicli Antica Pizzeria Nightingale Nomad Nook Nuba Oakwood Canadian Bistro OLO OPUS Bar Osteria Savio Volpe Oyama Sausage Co. Pallet Coffee Roasters Pat’s Pub & BrewHouse Pidgin Pizzeria Farina Pointe Restaurant at the Wickaninnish Inn, The Pourhouse Railtown Cafe Railtown Catering Rain Or Shine Ice Cream Red Wagon, The Revolver Coffee Rocky Mountain Flatbread Co. Royal Dinette Salt Tasting Room Savoury Chef Shaughnessy Restaurant Shebeen Whisk(e)y House Shelter Six Acres Sophie’s Cosmic Cafe Sorella Stable House, The Tableau Bar Bistro Tacofino Tavola Terra Breads Thierry Thomas Haas Chocolates & Patisserie Timber Timbertrain Coffee Roasters Torafuku Tractor Foods Truffles Fine Foods Two Rivers Specialty Meats UBC Farm Uncommon Cafe, The Urban Digs Farm Uva Wine & Cocktail Bar Vancouver Aquarium’s Ocean Wise™ Program Via Tevere Pizzeria Napoletana Vij’s Restaurant Virtuous Pie West Restaurant Wildebeest Wolf In The Fog YEW seafood

Lorem Ipsum is simply dummy text of the printing and typesetting industry. Lorem Ipsum has been the industry's standard dummy text ever since the 1500s, when an unknown printer took a galley of type and scrambled it to make a type specimen book. It has survived not only five centuries, but also the leap into electronic typesetting, remaining essentially unchanged. It was .

Lorem Ipsum is simply dummy text of the printing and typesetting industry. Lorem Ipsum has been the industry's standard dummy text ever since the 1500s, when an unknown printer took a galley of type and scrambled it to make a type specimen book. It has survived not only five centuries, but also the leap into electronic typesetting, remaining essentially unchanged. It was .