BAKER | Making Extra Awesome Eggnog Shortbread Sandwich Super Mega Cookies

December 23, 2013 


by Michelle Sproule | After posting a photo of these beauties on Instagram the other day, I promised to give our readers/followers the recipe, because eggnog plus icing plus shortbread! Seriously, how awesome is that? They don’t have a name, despite the headline, but rest assured, it’s the ultimate holiday season cookie, and a sweet little Christmas present from our kitchen to yours. Get started after the jump.

This is a hard cookie to screw up. If there’s any trick to it, it’s the baking time. Shortbread can be finicky, and mustn’t by over-baked, so watch your oven like a hawk. Be sure to make your icing first. Take your time so you get your flavour perfect.


1/2 cup soft butter
1 1/2 cups icing sugar
3-4 drops Eggnog flavour



- Combine butter and icing sugar in a mixing bowl until smooth.
- Add Eggnog flavour (to taste), mix again.
- Set aside, occasionally dipping pinky in “to check”


1 cup soft butter
1/2 cup cornstarch
1/2 cup icing sugar
1/2 tsp salt
2 cups flour



- Preheat oven to 350.
- Add cornstarch to butter in mixing bowl and combine with wooden spoon until smooth.
- Add icing sugar and salt to mixture and combine with wooden spoon until smooth.


- Add flour a half a cup at a time, mixing until incorporated.


- Divide your dough into two balls.


- Flour a large cutting board. With rolling pin, roll dough into thin sheet.
- Using a small, circular cookie cutter (I use the rim of a tempered glass), cut and place cookies on baking sheet.
- Bake for 10-15 minutes, eyeballing to make sure they don’t brown.
- transfer to cooling rack for 10-15 minutes


- Spread a generous amount of icing to flat side of one cookie.


- Place flat side of another cookie on top to create a sandwich.


For my most recent batch, I dusted the tops with some vanilla bean salt from The Salt Dispensary. Not essential, but it was awesome and it’s always fun to experiment. Enjoy!

One Response to “BAKER | Making Extra Awesome Eggnog Shortbread Sandwich Super Mega Cookies”

  1. jc on December 24th, 2013 12:21 am

    Where do you get egg nog flavouring?